NKHIDDENGULAG
  • Home
  • About the Camps
    • Introduction
    • Kwan-li-so vs. Kyo-hwa-so
    • Locations
    • HRNK Reports
    • UN Commission of Inquiry
    • Transitional Justice
  • Blog
  • Victims
    • Prisoners
    • Women
    • Disappeared Persons
  • HRNK
    • About us
    • HRNK Insider
  • Donate

NK HIdden Gulag Blog

Young Professionals Writing Program (YPWP)

Why Ignoring Human Rights in U.S.-DPRK Diplomacy Is a Grave Mistake

7/1/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture


​By Jeune Kim, HRNK Research Intern
Edited by Rosa Park, HRNK Director of Programs and Editor, and Camille Freestone, HRNK Research Intern


July 1, 2020

It is a grave mistake to engage diplomatically with North Korea and ignore its human rights abuses. Under Kim Jong-un, the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea (DPRK) has expressed its interest in a peace treaty with the United States.[1] In the past year, President Trump and Kim Jong-Un have indicated that they would like to usher in a new era of U.S.-DPRK relations based on a stable peace regime on the Korean peninsula.[2]

​After more than 30 years of diplomacy, the issue of human rights has not been included in negotiations with North Korea. During the Clinton administration, the United States and North Korea signed the Agreed Framework in 1994 to freeze North Korea’s operation and construction of nuclear reactors. In the framework, both sides committed “not to nuclearize the Korean Peninsula” and “to move toward normalizing economic and political relations.”[3] However, in 2002, Pyongyang admitted to facilitating a uranium-enrichment program to build nuclear weapons and, in December, announced it would restart its nuclear facilities, effectively ending the Agreed Framework and withdrawing from the nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.[4] In August 2003, the Six Party Talks brought together representatives from South and North Korea, China, Japan, Russia, and the United States. After two years of negotiations, it issued a Joint Statement on initial steps to denuclearization. However, this too proved unsuccessful in halting Pyongyang’s nuclear program. When President Obama attempted to revive the Six Party Talks in 2009, the plan was rejected by North Korea, and despite an increase in sanctions, North Korea continued to test its nuclear and missile capabilities.[5] After the summits between President Trump and Kim Jong-un, North Korea committed to denuclearization on the Korean Peninsula and President Trump declared that North Korea’s nuclear problem had been “largely solved.”[6] However, follow-up negotiations have reached a stalemate, there is no agreed-upon road map for denuclearization,[7] and North Korea continued to test missiles and vowed to boost its nuclear program.[8]

Dismantling North Korea’s nuclear program has been the center of U.S. engagement policy. However, these endeavors have failed because the North Korean regime has failed to act in good faith on its commitment to bilateral and multilateral agreements. While the inclusion of human rights in U.S. engagement policy does not automatically guarantee the success of denuclearization policy, it is necessary to establish good faith with North Korea and for the success of any engagement with North Korea. 
Historically, the United States has pursued four main objectives in diplomatic discussions with North Korea: 1) enhancing regional stability; 2) thwarting weapons proliferation; 3) encouraging North-South dialogue; and 4) protecting U.S.-ROK cooperation. Under President Trump, diplomacy with North Korea has focused on establishing a peace regime on the Korean peninsula,[9] the denuclearization of North Korea, the normalization of diplomatic relations upon denuclearization, and the repatriation of U.S. POW/MIA remains. North Korea has also come under fire for its illicit activities in the international drug trade, counterfeiting schemes, and cybercrimes. 

While these objectives and illicit activities are, without a doubt, of great importance, ignoring the human rights violations of the North Korean regime at the negotiating table will prove to be an impediment to the goal of successfully brokering peace on the Korean peninsula. The North Korean human rights issue should be included in the United States’ engagement policy based on universal human rights, responsibility, and strategy.

Universal Human Rights

The violation of human rights is wrong regardless of where they happen. In response to the atrocities experienced during World War II, the United Nations General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights to guarantee the protection of individual rights and freedoms of every individual everywhere.[10] Torture, forced labor, and denial of access to food and basic necessities are immoral, condemnable, and have been prohibited by international laws and treaties. Despite North Korea’s ratification of several human rights treaties such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; and the United Nations Charter, they continue to violate these commitments and systematically abuse the human rights of their own citizens. 

Responsibility

The world order is no longer a hegemony, but the United States still plays a vital role as a leader in world affairs. It remains an essential political and economic player. Having ratified the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and as a leading member of the United Nations (UN) and a permanent member of the UN Security Council, the United States has an obligation to uphold international human rights law and oppose policies and practices encouraging human rights abuses. Emphasizing the issue of human rights is not imposing “American values”[11] onto its adversaries; rather, it demonstrates our responsibility to uphold international standards, norms, and commitment to human dignity. 

Strategy

The United States should include human rights as a pillar of engagement with North Korea not only because it is the right and responsible thing to do, but also because it is strategically viable. Pressuring North Korea on its human rights abuses demonstrates U.S. commitment to human rights and democracy. This approach would uphold the human rights of North Korean citizens and advance core national interests: transparency, democracy, rule of law, justice, and accountability. Furthermore, the United States demonstrating a deep commitment to protecting the rights of North Koreans could maintain the platform to garner international support and build coalitions to pressure North Korea. As it becomes clear that unilateral efforts to influence North Korea are limited in scope and staying power, international solutions and multilateral pressure may prove to be more successful—not only in regard to human rights—but also with denuclearization, weapons proliferation, and international crime.[12] The United States has focused on a carrot and stick approach to its negotiations with North Korea. It must now increase its efforts to shape North Korea’s strategic environment.[13] Other nations, such as China, Japan, and Russia, should have a vested interest in peace and denuclearization on the Korean peninsula. In an increasingly multipolar and globalized world, the United States will come to the negotiating table with a stronger hand if it has the unified support of other nations. 
​
Conclusion

It is impossible to establish a stable and lasting peace regime on the Korean peninsula as long as North Korea continues to perpetrate obscene violations of human rights. Allowing North Korea to label criticism of its human rights record as “hostile policy”[14] and dictate the narrative on human rights is not only irrational, but it is also a threat to the United States, to the international community, and, most of all, to North Korean citizens. The United States must make it clear to North Korea, and to any other aspiring rogue regime, that it will not tolerate such brutal and internationally prohibited behavior. The United States has now embarked on an unprecedented chapter in its relationship with North Korea. Whether it ends as another failure or successful stabilization of the peninsula depends on bringing North Korea’s repressive policies and brutal practices to heel and achieving the protection of human rights in North Korea. 

Jeune Kim is a second-year student pursuing an M.A. in Global Policy Studies at the LBJ School of Public Affairs at the University of Texas. Her specialization is in Security, Law, and Diplomacy.



[1] See Patrick McEachern, “What Does North Korea Want?,” The Foreign Service Journal (October 2019), https://www.afsa.org/what-does-north-korea-want. North Korea considers a peace treaty as a pretext to end the permanent stationing of U.S. troops in South Korea. This is also what they mean by denuclearization of the Korean peninsula.
[2] Although the United States and North Korea view peaceful relations differently, the Singapore Summit Joint Statement signed by President Trump and Chairman Kim states, “The United States and the DPRK will join their efforts to build a lasting and stable peace regime on the Korean Peninsula.” Available at https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/joint-statement-president-donald-j-trump-united-states-america-chairman-kim-jong-un-democratic-peoples-republic-korea-singapore-summit/. 
[3] “Agreed Framework between the United States of America and the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea,” October 21, 1994, https://www.armscontrol.org/documents/af.
[4] “The U.S.-North Korean Agreed Framework at a Glance,” July 2018, https://www.armscontrol.org/factsheets/agreedframework
[5] “North Korean Nuclear Negotiations: 1985-2019”, https://www.cfr.org/timeline/north-korean-nuclear-negotiations
[6] “Remarks by President Trump in Press Gaggle,” June 15, 2018, https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefings-statements/remarks-president-trump-press-gaggle/
[7] See Daniel Wertz, “The U.S., North Korea, and Nuclear Diplomacy,” National Committee on North Korea (October 2018) https://www.ncnk.org/resources/briefing-papers/all-briefing-papers/history-u.s.-dprk-relations#footnote27_ff9hzt1
[8] See Choe Sang-hun, “North Korea Vows to Boost Nuclear Program, Saying U.S. Diplomacy Failed,” New York Times, June 11, 2020, https://www.nytimes.com/2020/06/11/world/asia/north-korea-nuclear-trump.html
[9] Ibid, Singapore Summit Joint Statement. 
[10] “Universal Declaration of Human Rights: History of the Document”, https://www.un.org/en/sections/universal-declaration/history-document/index.html
[11] See Ted Piccone, “Tillerson says goodbye to human rights diplomacy,” Brookings, May 5, 2017. 
[12] Although some experts argue that multilateral efforts such as the Six Party Talks yielded little results and took too long (see Jayshree Bajoria and Beina Xu, “The Six Party Talks on North Korea’s Nuclear Program,” Council on Foreign Relations, September 30, 2013), recent bilateral talks have not improved relations or progress on denuclearization (see Scott Snyder, “Why U.S.-North Korea Talks Failed Again,” Council on Foreign Relations, October 8, 2019).
[13] See North Korea after Kim Jong-il: Still Dangerous and Erratic: Hearing Before the House Committee of Foreign Affairs, 112th Cong.2 (2012) (statement of Scott Snyder, Senior Fellow for Korea Studies and Director of  the Program on U.S.-Korea Policy at the Council on Foreign Relations).
[14] See “Report of the Commission of Inquiry on Human Rights in the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea,” UN General Assembly document A/HRC/25/63, February 7, 2014; Amb. Ja Song Nam, “Letter dated 20 December 2014 from the Permanent Representative of the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea to the United Nations addressed to the President of the Security Council,” UN Security Council document S/2014/930.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Dedication

    ​HRNK staff members and interns wish to dedicate this program to our colleagues Katty Chi and Miran Song.

    A native of Chile and graduate of the London School of Economics, Katty became a North Korean human rights defender in her early 20s. Katty was chief of international affairs with the North Korea Strategy Center (NKSC) in Seoul from 2010 to 2014 and worked with the Seoul Office of Liberty in North Korea (LiNK) from 2019 to 2020. A remarkable member of our small North Korean human rights community, Katty brought inspiration and good humor to all. Katty passed away in Seoul in May 2020, at the young age of 32. She is survived by her parents and brother living in Chile.

    A graduate of Kyung Hee University and The Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy, Miran was a research intern at HRNK from 2012 to 2013. After graduating from Fletcher, Miran fulfilled her long-cherished dream to work in the field with international NGOs and South Korean government agencies, dedicating herself to sustainable development projects in Uganda and Ethiopia. A staunch human rights defender and passionate humanitarian, she lived her short, difficult, and meaningful life feeling blessed by the opportunity to help others. She passed away in 2022, at the young age of 31.

    With the YPWP series, we endeavor to honor Katty and Miran’s life and work.

    Greg Scarlatoiu

    If you have any questions, please contact us at outreach@hrnk.org.

    Categories

    All
    김일성 초상휘장
    생활총화
    청년동맹위원장과 청소년지도원
    2010 World Cup Team
    AllSource Analysis
    Arduous March
    Bitcoin
    Bithumb
    Blockchain
    China
    Coincheck
    Concentration-camps
    Crimes-against-humanity
    Cryptocurrency
    Crypto Industry
    Cyberattack
    Cybercrime
    Cyber Crime
    David Hawk
    Donald Trump
    DPRK
    DPRK Sanctions
    DPRK Sports
    FATF
    Federal Reserve Bank
    FEMA Conspiracy Theory
    FIFA
    FinCen
    Forced Abortion
    Forced Marriage
    Gender Discrimination
    Gender Repression
    Global Programme On Cybercrime
    Google Earth
    Greg Scarlatoiu
    Gulags
    Hidden Gulag
    HRNK
    Human Rights
    Human Trafficking
    Illicit
    Infanticide
    Informal Markets
    International Community
    Jangmadang
    Jangmadang Generation
    Kim Il-sung
    Kim Il-sung Badge
    Kim Il-sung Cho-sang-hui-jang
    Kim Jong-suk
    Kim Jong Un
    Kim Jong-un
    Kim Regime
    Kwan Li So
    Kwan-li-so
    Kyo Hwa So
    Kyo-hwa-so
    Laogai
    May Day Stadium
    Monero
    NK Athletes
    North Korea
    North Korean Athletes
    North Korean Economy
    North Korean Hackers
    North Korean Markets
    Olympic Games
    Payment Services Act
    Political Prisoners
    Prison Camps
    Prisoner Testimony
    PyeongChang Olympics
    Red Youth Guard
    Refugees
    Saeng-hwal-chong-hwa
    Satellite Imagery
    School
    Self-criticism
    Sexual Exploitation
    Sexual Violence
    Singapore Summit
    Summit
    Technology
    The Game Of Their Lives
    Torture
    Treasury
    Trump Kim Summit
    UN Commission Of Inquiry
    United Nations
    UN Sanctions
    U.S. Treasury Department
    Wanna Cry
    World Cup
    Youth Alliance Chairman And Youth Instructors

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    October 2021
    August 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    August 2018
    June 2018
    August 2017
    March 2017
    August 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    July 2015

      Submit a Blog Post or Ask a Question:

    Submit

    Categories

    All
    김일성 초상휘장
    생활총화
    청년동맹위원장과 청소년지도원
    2010 World Cup Team
    AllSource Analysis
    Arduous March
    Bitcoin
    Bithumb
    Blockchain
    China
    Coincheck
    Concentration-camps
    Crimes-against-humanity
    Cryptocurrency
    Crypto Industry
    Cyberattack
    Cybercrime
    Cyber Crime
    David Hawk
    Donald Trump
    DPRK
    DPRK Sanctions
    DPRK Sports
    FATF
    Federal Reserve Bank
    FEMA Conspiracy Theory
    FIFA
    FinCen
    Forced Abortion
    Forced Marriage
    Gender Discrimination
    Gender Repression
    Global Programme On Cybercrime
    Google Earth
    Greg Scarlatoiu
    Gulags
    Hidden Gulag
    HRNK
    Human Rights
    Human Trafficking
    Illicit
    Infanticide
    Informal Markets
    International Community
    Jangmadang
    Jangmadang Generation
    Kim Il-sung
    Kim Il-sung Badge
    Kim Il-sung Cho-sang-hui-jang
    Kim Jong-suk
    Kim Jong Un
    Kim Jong-un
    Kim Regime
    Kwan Li So
    Kwan-li-so
    Kyo Hwa So
    Kyo-hwa-so
    Laogai
    May Day Stadium
    Monero
    NK Athletes
    North Korea
    North Korean Athletes
    North Korean Economy
    North Korean Hackers
    North Korean Markets
    Olympic Games
    Payment Services Act
    Political Prisoners
    Prison Camps
    Prisoner Testimony
    PyeongChang Olympics
    Red Youth Guard
    Refugees
    Saeng-hwal-chong-hwa
    Satellite Imagery
    School
    Self-criticism
    Sexual Exploitation
    Sexual Violence
    Singapore Summit
    Summit
    Technology
    The Game Of Their Lives
    Torture
    Treasury
    Trump Kim Summit
    UN Commission Of Inquiry
    United Nations
    UN Sanctions
    U.S. Treasury Department
    Wanna Cry
    World Cup
    Youth Alliance Chairman And Youth Instructors

    RSS Feed

Contact Us

Picture

© 2022 Committee for Human Rights in North Korea. All rights reserved.

DONATE
  • Home
  • About the Camps
    • Introduction
    • Kwan-li-so vs. Kyo-hwa-so
    • Locations
    • HRNK Reports
    • UN Commission of Inquiry
    • Transitional Justice
  • Blog
  • Victims
    • Prisoners
    • Women
    • Disappeared Persons
  • HRNK
    • About us
    • HRNK Insider
  • Donate